Blog

Oct 17, 2024

Best bike mudguards | Cycling Weekly

They're hardly bling, but a good set of guards will help you to ride through the winter in comfort. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it

They're hardly bling, but a good set of guards will help you to ride through the winter in comfort.

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Here’s how it works.

14th October 2024: The update included a new review. Along with more information on how we test mudguards, what we look for and answering more questions about mudguards/fenders.

The function of a Fender/Mudguard is simple. Keep spray from your winter tyres reaching your kit and body, dry riders are warm ones. Mudguards/fenders can also protect your bike, keeping your drivetrain clean and increasing the longevity of your components. The rule of thumb is the longer the guard, the greater the level of protection. Mudguards/Fenders don't replace the best winter cycling jackets but they do help them perform better.

Fitting mudguards/fenders to some bikes can be challenging. Many will hang up their best road bike in favour of an endurance road bike or gravel bike for this reason. Offering greater clearances around the tyre and dedicated mounts for ease of fitting mudguards/fenders. Choose to continue riding one of the best aero bikes year round, then brands like SKS with the Raceblade XL Pro offer great clip-on options.

For this guide, I have selected six of our highest-rated mudguard/fender options for winter road cycling. Tested relentlessly throughout wet and cold UK & PNW winters, our best overall stamp goes to the Portland Design Works full metal fenders. PDW guards offer great protection in a variety of widths. With our honourable mention going to the Ass Savers Win Wing 2, its minimal coverage keeps you surprisingly dry.

Best Overall

Best Overall

At the top end of most people's budget, the PDW Full Metals fenders are easy to justify when they perform so well.

See more below

Best Budget

Best Budget

A personal favourite of mine when I was a full-time bike mechanic the fully adjustable struts of the Bontrager NCS guards are so simple to fit.

See more below

Best Clip-on

Best Clip-on

Considering how easy the SKS Raceblade Pros are to fit, they do an admirable job of keeping the worst of the muck and water off the rider.

See more below

You can trust Cycling Weekly. Our team of experts put in hard miles testing cycling tech and will always share honest, unbiased advice to help you choose. Find out more about how we test.

Full metal fenders that offer rattle-free cycling

Our expert review:

These anodised aluminium fenders/mudguards from Portland Design Works come in at an impressive 446g (as fitted) and they are able - with optional axle tabs - to fit bikes without traditional frame eyelets as well.

To stop your toes from clashing with the stay end caps, the Full Metal fenders/mudguards use a single stay design that is kept higher on the front fender than a double stay type. It made low-speed manoeuvring easier, although there was still toe overlap on my bike but that's the bike and not the mudguard's fault.

PDW's full-wrap offering were remarkably easy to fit and setup, and having discrete breakaway clips at both ends which was a nice touch. Once on the bike, they were super stiff which stopped any tire buzz, even when rocking the bike from side to side on a steep hill.

There are three widths available, and these 37mm wide mudguards are able to accommodate up to a 30mm tyre. They looked in proportion when using a 28mm tire and there was a good amount of space to the side of the tire.

Along with the silence, the stealthy look from the matt black finish keeps everything pretty discreet. These mudguards are really good and are well worth strong consideration despite the higher price than other options here.

Read our full Portland Design Works Full Metal fenders/mudguards review

side on shot of the Bontrager NCS mudguards, with 100% adjustable stays meaning not need for cutting.

Our expert review:

Bontrager's NCS fenders/mudguards have a clever trick up their stays: instead of trimming them to make them fit your bike properly, you adjust the length of the stays by sliding the two parts up or down as necessary, using the built-in clamps to then lock them in place - thus providing maximum coverage without the possibility of annoying extra faff.

With that extra-long coverage, our reviewer found that the Bontrager NCS fenders/mudguards offer more protection than many other ‘full-length’ mudguards. The rubber mudflaps at the ends of fenders further add to the length and help reduce road spray for your feet or friends, but these aren’t as long as we see on some other mudguard sets.

The Bontrager NCS fenders/mudguards come in a range of sizes: from 18-25mm for old-school road bikes and all the way up to 35-45mm for trendy new gravel bikes. The set we had on test was right in the middle, designed for 28-35mm 700c tyres - which is typical for winter bikes these days.

There is a mount on the rear fender for a Blendr light (also sold by Bontrager), but user reviews on Trek’s site suggest it’s been a bit fragile for some folks. We didn’t have an accompanying light for this review, so can’t comment directly on its performance - but it’s there if you would like to use it.

Read our full Bontrager NCS fenders/mudguards review

With their reinforced structure the Bluemels are durable and stiff

Our expert review:

SKS’s Bluemels Basic fenders/mudguards do a reasonably good job of keeping you dry. Their coverage isn’t as long as some - and our tester did find that you get spray over your feet from the front wheel and anyone following behind will still get a coating.

But that said, you perfectly well attach your own mudflaps to the Bluemels Basic and extend their spray protection that way. It’s simple (and cheap) enough to fashion a set from a few sheets of rubber - and there are even brands which offer funky designs, such as Raw Mudflap.

The construction consists of a sandwich of thin aluminium encased in plastic. It’s not quite as rigid as an all-metal design, but thanks to the sturdy stays, our tester didn’t have any issues with rubbing. But naturally, if you try to cram a wider tire than recommended - or if the clearance between your seatstays is particularly tight - you can still experience issues.

There are fenders / mudguards which do provide more coverage at a similar price - even within SKS’s own range, such as the SKS Longboards. If wet weather protection is most important to you, the choice between the two is pretty obvious. But there will be those who prefer the tidier looks of the Bluemels Basics.

Other rivals include Bontrager with their NCS fenders / mudguards that are longer and easier to fit, but more expensive and the Portland Design Works Full Metal Fenders which are absolutely brilliant but are more than double the price of the Bluemels Basics.

Read our full SKS Bluemels Basic fenders/mudguards review

Clip on and off as much as you need too

Our expert review:

The SKS Raceblade Pro XL Stealth Series guards tip the scales at 380 grams, when weighed with the rubber attachment straps. They are compatible with 700c wheels and tire widths of up to 32mm. The front fender provides a coverage of 565mm and the rear 730mm.

Testing these on both traditional round tubes and aero-profiled carbon frames, the SKS Raceblade Pro XL Stealth Series fits securely and is easy to make micro-adjustments with, to ensure that the clearances between the frame and tires are sufficient. The fenders are also very quick to remove for rides on dry days.

Naturally, you (and the people behind you) get less protection than with a set of full-length fenders. But as a lightweight and quick-to-remove set (perfect for bikes without mudguard eyelets), the SKS Raceblade Pro XL Stealth Series do a respectable job, keeping the worst of the muck off and leaving you warmer and more comfortable.

This, combined with the minimally fussy fitting, makes the SKS Raceblade Pro XL Stealth Series better than any of its clip-on competitors - which generally either don’t fit as well or don’t offer as good protection. Value-wise they are a bit more expensive than the competition, but they are also readily available for less online.

Read our full SKS Raceblade Pro XL Stealth Series review

Ultra light but with great coverage

Our expert review:

If all you knew about the Crud Mk3 Roadracers was their impressively low weight you would be forgiven for thinking they didn't offer much coverage. That is the one thing that really impressed me. For 260 grams you get a full coverage fender.

Despite being in the Clip-on category the Roadracers velcro on to your fork and cable tied to the rear. Which creates a clean look, reduces abrasion to paintwork and is a totally tool-free installation process. I did the initial install in about 15 minutes, but as will all mudguards what followed was a lifetime of fettling.

Once I was finally happy with the position I did forget the Roadracers were fitted and lived a trouble-free existence throughout the test.

Read our full Crud Mk3 Roadracer Mudguard/fender review

For a clip on mudguard the Flinger Race Pro is super sturdy

Our expert review:

The Flinger Race Pro guards are an easy-to-install set of clip-on mudguards that fit securely to road bikes without specific eyelets for mounting 'guards.

They feel light on the bike relative to some other fenders/mudguards and, with excellent coverage, the Race Pros keep you, your mates and your bike much dryer than going bare or using an 'asssaver' style fender.

In the box comes a rear guard with stays attached, a rear guard extension, adjustable stays with an attachment foot, a short bracket and four rubber attachment strips. The attachment strips wrap around the seat and chain stays then link onto a hook in the bracket that holds the guard in place.

The guard is a tight squeeze, and so in the case of our tester, he couldn't fit the entire product onto his bike. That said, it was functional even with one part of the guards missing from the bike.

Read our full Flinger Race Pro Fender/mudguard full review

Might look small but it offers a surprising amount of coverage

Ass Savers Win Wing 2 fender: It is never going to replace full mudguards/fenders or even some of the better high-coverage clip-on systems like the SKS Raceblades. For a tiny Clip-on mudguard/fender, the Win Wing 2 does an absolutely incredible job. So much so, that our Pacific Northwest-based US editor Rook awarded it 5 stars out of 5.

Why is that significant?

PNW, like the UK, gets a lot of weather. A lot of rain specifically and Rook found the Win Wing 2 does an excellent job of keeping your chamois and back dry regardless of how wet and muddy there was.

Read Rooks full Ass Saver Win Wing 2 Fender review

First and foremost comes the hard miles through the UK and Pacific Northwest winter inclement winters. The Cycling Weekly dedicates swathes of time every winter to testing mudguards/fenders looking for the sweet spot. Rattle-free, easy to use, durable with high levels of coverage mudguard/fenders.

Large parts of our testing are dedicated to the fitting methods and adjustability of every mudguard/fender set. For so many mudguards/fenders can be one of the most annoying things to fit onto a bicycle. So, our aim is to only recommend the ones we know everyone can fit at home with a few simple tools.

Also high on our hit list is to test durability. Mudguards/fenders get bashed around a lot, moving the bike around the garage, knocked by your toes or damaged in a crash. This comes back to the fitting, you don't want to have to adjust every 5 minutes.

Finally, style and finish. Us cyclists are a fickle bunch and bolting fenders onto a bike is never a delicate undertaking. So, they have to look good, be able to track the lines of the bike and survive a winter of salt, grit, mud and water eating away at all the fits.

Let’s get this out of the way before we go any further. Bike fenders/mudguards are cool! We pay hundreds of pounds/dollars for the best winter jacket yet refuse to admit mudguards/fenders do a far better job for a fraction of the cost.

There are, broadly speaking, two types of fender/mudguards: those for frames with dedicated fixing points. – and those for frames without, known as clip-on mudguards. Of course, even if your bike has mudguard eyes there’s no reason why you can’t use clip-ons if you’re looking for a lightweight, easily removable solution.

Shun them at your peril. Turning up for a winter club/group ride on a mudguard-less bike will not win you any friends. Many clubs still enforce rules about when you should fit guards. Nothing worse than sitting in a bunch behind the guy with no fenders.

Mudguards/Fenders also play a huge part in maintaining your bike over the winter months. Mudguards/fenders do a fantastic job of protecting your frame, keeping all the water, grit and salt from being flung at your nice paint job. More importantly, they protect your expensive drivetrain, prolonging the life of costly parts like chainrings and cassettes.

There is no one answer to this question, as it depends on which brand and model of mudguard/fender you fit.

If your frame has dedicated mudguard fixtures, then the likes of the PDW full metals and the SKS Bluemels mudguard/fenders will require the stays cutting. Once this is done it is a simple bolt-on job.

For most Clip-on mudguards/fenders it should just be as simple as using the fixtures and fittings provided. This is usually using the provided cable ties or silicone straps. Great examples of these are the SKS Raceblade Pros.

There is nuance in fitting any set of mudguards/fenders and one will never fit the same on two bikes. The real art is getting them in just the right place and getting them to stay put. This is not a job you should tackle ten minutes before the Sunday club run.

Fitted incorrectly, mudguards/fenders can be a pretty serious accident risk. It's worth taking your time and making sure they are secured correctly. For this reason, It is one of the few jobs I always recommend people get done at their local bike shop.

Firstly, check the tyre you plan to run fits in the fender. The rule of thumb is whatever marked tyre size you run add 10mm for good all-round clearance. For example, if you run a marked 28mm tyre purchase guards at least 38mm wide.

You need to make sure you purchase the right fixing type. Does your frame and fork have dedicated fender mounting points? If not, think about a Clip-on option.

With Road bike tyre sizes and rim widths increasing in recent years, it is not uncommon to see 23mm internal rims and 30/32mm tyres on stock bikes. So, the need for wider fenders has become commonplace. For some alternative options, especially for those running 35mm or above consider some of these, the best mudguards/fenders for gravel bikes.

The latest race content, interviews, features, reviews and expert buying guides, direct to your inbox!

Like so many, Matt got his start in the bicycle industry wheedling allen keys and the occasional hammer at his local IBD. Matt grew up mountain biking the flint-strewn hills of the North Downs but was convinced during his time with Evans Cycles' in-house brand Pinnacle and Hoy Bikes, to take up gravel cycling and bikepacking. Spotting the changing industry, Matt jumped at the opportunity to become an E-Bike designer. Winning several awards with Cairn Cycles and their range of Gravel E-bikes.

These days Matt will more than likely have a toddler sat shotgun and balance bike lassoed to his back somewhere on the South Downs. What time he does get to ride for himself, he chooses to take his Sonder Camino to just about anywhere that's quiet, off the beaten track or has some historical point of interest.

The Tour de France stage win record holder says that his plan is to head into cycling management

By Adam BecketPublished 15 October 24

These wireless helmet speakers are a unique near-ear audio system that allows cyclists to play music or podcasts without sacrificing spatial awareness

By Samantha NakataPublished 14 October 24